By: ALA Staff

/

Reading time: 7.9 min.

The hunters you pick will shape your income, your property and your peace of mind for years.

Screen hunters the way you would screen any tenant: use a written application, interview them, call the landowners they have leased from, walk the property together and confirm their liability insurance before anyone signs. A careful choice up front prevents most of the problems landowners run into later.

Key takeaways

  • Extension specialists call careful selection of hunters the most important protection a leasing landowner has.
  • Start with a written application and a phone interview, then meet your top candidates on the property.
  • Call the landowners they have leased from and ask about any hunting law violations.
  • Get a copy of their liability insurance, with you named as an additional insured, before the season opens.
  • Put everything you agreed on in a written lease that every hunter in the group signs.

Why Choosing the Right Hunters Matters Most

When you lease hunting rights, you are giving people you may not know well the right to be on your land, often with guests, for months at a time. They will drive your roads, hang stands in your trees and walk past your fences, equipment and livestock.

That is why University of Missouri Extension puts it bluntly in its Landowners’ Guide to Lease Hunting in Missouri: “The most important and best liability insurance is the careful selection of lessees.” A good group pays on time, follows your rules, reports problems and helps keep trespassers out. A poor fit can cost you far more than one season of lease income.

Decide What You Want Before You Advertise

Screening is easier when you know what you are screening for. Before you take calls, write down:

  • How many hunters you will allow at one time and in total.
  • Which game and seasons are included, and any harvest limits.
  • Areas that are off-limits, such as the house, barns, livestock pastures or crop fields during harvest.
  • Rules on guests, vehicles, alcohol, stands and food plots.
  • Who else keeps access, such as family members or friends who already hunt there.

Knowing your price range helps too. Our guide to hunting lease prices per acre covers what drives rates.

Hunter in camouflage scanning a snowy ridge for deer at sunrise

Where to Find Good Hunters

The best leads often come from people you already know. University of Maryland Extension suggests offering neighbors and local hunters who already use the property the first chance to lease, which can also reduce hard feelings when you start charging.

Other common routes include referrals from other landowners, local hunting clubs, farm and sporting goods store bulletin boards, local classified ads and online lease listing services. Base Camp Leasing is one option for listing your land and reaching hunters looking for a lease. Whichever route you use, the screening steps below still apply.

Start With a Written Application and an Interview

University of Arkansas Extension suggests sending an application form to everyone who responds to your ad, then interviewing promising applicants before signing anything (Wildlife Leases and Liability Issues on Private Lands). Maryland Extension recommends starting with phone interviews so you can ask the questions that matter most to you.

A simple application should ask for each hunter's name and contact information, the size of the group, the landowners they have leased from before and proof of liability insurance.

Questions Worth Asking

  • Who will hunt here, and will you bring guests? How often?
  • What game and seasons do you plan to hunt, and with what weapons?
  • Where have you leased or hunted before, and why did you leave?
  • Have you or anyone in your group had a hunting or fishing violation?
  • Has everyone completed a hunter education course?
  • Do you plan to form a club, and who else might use the property later?
  • Are you willing to help with tasks like posting boundaries or reporting trespassers?

Pay attention to how they talk about past landowners and rules. Keep your decision based on practical factors like experience, references and insurance. Arkansas Extension notes that it is illegal to discriminate based on race, ethnicity, age, gender or physical handicap.

Red Flags to Watch For

No single answer should rule someone out, but these deserve a closer look before you sign:

  • Reluctance to give references, or past landlords who never call back.
  • A group that keeps growing as you talk, or vague answers about who will actually hunt.
  • Pushback on carrying liability insurance or signing a written lease.
  • Pressure to skip the property visit or to start hunting before the paperwork is done.
  • Complaints about every past landowner they have dealt with.

Trust your instincts. You will be dealing with this group every season, so it pays to choose people you are comfortable calling when something goes wrong.

Check References and Past Violations

Arkansas Extension recommends asking applicants for the landowners they have leased from and talking to those landowners directly. Good questions for a past landlord:

  • Did they pay on time and follow the lease?
  • Did they respect boundaries, gates, crops and livestock?
  • Did they control their guests?
  • Did they leave the property clean?
  • Would you lease to them again?

The same publication advises finding out whether applicants have had any hunting law violations and whether they have taken a hunter education course. What violation records are available to the public differs from state to state, so ask your state wildlife agency what it can share, and ask applicants directly.

Farm field with a hunting blind along the edge

Meet Your Top Candidates on the Property

Once you have narrowed the list, Maryland Extension suggests meeting a few likely candidates at the property before you decide. A walk-through lets you:

  • Show boundaries, gates, roads and off-limits areas.
  • Point out hazards such as old wells, ponds, steep banks and buildings.
  • Explain where stands, blinds and parking are allowed.
  • See how the group listens and whether they ask good questions.

Take notes and photos during the visit. They are a useful record of the property's condition before the lease starts.

Confirm Their Insurance Before Anyone Hunts

Maryland Extension notes that general farm insurance usually does not cover fee hunting, so insurance needs a close look. Missouri Extension recommends requiring lessees to carry liability insurance, paid for by the hunters, with an additional insured option for the landowner. Arkansas Extension adds these checks:

  • Get and keep a copy of the hunter's policy.
  • Make sure the policy is with a reputable, financially sound insurer.
  • Make sure you are named on the policy.
  • Be sure the policy indemnifies you if a judgment is obtained against you.

Their policy is one layer of protection, not the only one. Read more in Do Hunters on My Land Need Their Own Liability Insurance?

Elevated hunting stand overlooking an autumn field

Put Your Expectations in a Written Lease

Screening only works if the rules you discussed are written down. Arkansas Extension calls a written lease "a vital tool for protecting you and your assets" and warns against informal arrangements. For groups, Missouri Extension recommends naming one person as the leader and main contact and having every member sign. Arkansas Extension also suggests keeping a list of all club members with names and addresses, and requiring the lessee to screen and monitor other hunters and guests.

Many landowners start new groups on a one-season lease and renew if things go well. Have an attorney review the lease before you use it, and see our clause-by-clause hunting lease agreement checklist for what to include.

The Bottom Line

The rent you charge matters, but who you lease to matters more. Take the time to use an application, interview applicants, call past landlords, walk the property together and get proof of insurance before anyone signs. A careful process protects your land, your income and your relationship with your neighbors.

This article is for general education and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Sources: University of Missouri Extension, Landowners' Guide to Lease Hunting in Missouri (G9420, rev. 2024); University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension, Wildlife Leases and Liability Issues on Private Lands (FSA9089); University of Maryland Extension, Hunting Lease Enterprise (RES-07).

Sponsored

Vacant land insurance banner advertising coverage for up to 750 acres

Frequently asked questions

Ask how many people will hunt, what game and seasons they plan to hunt, where they have leased before, whether they have any hunting law violations, whether they have taken a hunter education course and whether they carry liability insurance. Their answers, plus a reference check, tell you most of what you need to know.

Yes. Extension specialists recommend asking applicants for the landowners they have leased from before and calling those landowners. A past landlord can tell you whether the group paid on time, followed the rules and left the property in good shape.

Most extension guides recommend requiring it in the lease, with you named as an additional insured. Get a copy of the policy before the season starts, and keep your own landowner liability coverage too, since their policy may not cover every claim.

Yes. Extension guidance says all members of a group should sign the lease, with one person named as the leader and main contact. Ask for a roster with each member's name and contact information.

You can choose lessees based on things like experience, references, insurance and fit with your rules. University of Arkansas Extension notes that it is illegal to discriminate based on race, ethnicity, age, gender or physical handicap, so base your decision on those practical factors.

Share this article
Author: ALA Staff

The American Landowner Alliance team writes practical guides for rural landowners on protecting, managing, earning from and passing on their land. Our articles draw on state law, university extension services and conservation agencies, with sources linked in every post.